The Meaning of Luxury

FrancesLCE5

27 October 2024

No Comments

The Definition of Luxury

Across the world, the term ‘luxury’ and similar phrases, such as luxurious, are commonly used to market products and services. This includes our offerings here at Chamonix Exclusive, where we frequently refer to luxury chalets in Chamonix and luxury holidays to convey what we consider an exclusive and prestigious experience. But our benchmark of what luxury looks like and means, whilst similar to some, is very different compared to others. So, can we all legitimately claim luxury when the standards are so different? We’ve delved into popular opinions and academic research to try and find out.

Luxury’s Heritage Was Not Quite So Glamorous

 

Some might be surprised that the Latin words associated with being the forefathers of the formulation of luxury have an interesting and somewhat contrasting meaning to today’s. Rooted in the Latin terms “luxus” and “luxuria,” both reference concepts of excess and opulence, but “luxus” denotes lavishness and extravagance, often carrying a negative connotation associated with moral decay, while “luxuria” emphasizes indulgence and sensual pleasure, sometimes associated, many centuries ago, to immoral behaviour. This duality reflects the ancient Roman perspective on the dangers of excess, suggesting that what is luxurious can also lead to a loss of restraint and virtue. While luxury has become more socially accepted since the 17th and 18th Centuries, the modern interpretations of luxury can still be susceptible to our historical concerns regarding excessive indulgence and morality.

Luxury Amongst Populalist Sources

 

Today, a quick search on Google revealed that the noun “luxury” has numerous complementary and nuanced definitions, with some claiming the moral high ground on what it is supposed to mean. Consulting the Collins Oxford Dictionary to hopefully set us on the right track. They defined luxury as:

“enjoyment of rich, very comfortable living; enjoyable but not essential thing.“

It also describes the adjective “luxurious” as ‘pertaining to or providing luxury; sumptuous.’This serves as a starting point; however, conveying this felt somewhat limited and superficial, so we entered the academic world to see if this would shed more light on the perceived meaning and application of the term “luxury.”

Historical Research Into Luxury

 

Luxury has been widely studied across various fields, including marketing, sociology, and economics. Veblen’s (1899) sociocultural perspective introduced the idea of ‘conspicuous consumption’, which argues that luxury goods serve as a status symbol, differentiating the wealthy from others. He noted that individuals purchase luxury items not only for their utility but also for the social prestige they confer. Eastman et al. (1999) take a similar view that luxury items psychologically support people’s self-esteem and social identity. They buy and own luxury goods, often to express their individuality and enhance their self-concept. A Range Rover, for example, in modern-day Britain portrays affluence, a sense of the outdoor, go-anywhere spirit, and a higher status for some, reinforced by the Range Rover’s famous higher driving position.

Recognising Luxury Is Often Linked To The Experience

 

While most research in the 20th Century focused primarily on luxury products, academics Pine and Gilmore (1999) expanded the concept to luxury experiences. Their research and findings introduced the “experience economy”. This suggested luxury brands could and often should focus on creating memorable experiences for consumers, making the act of consumption valuable beyond the mere possession of goods. From our own experience, we would concur. While a fantastic chalet (product) is important and will help, it still needs the other ‘experience’ ingredients (e.g. service, discretion, attention to detail, etc.) to make it memorable and, dare we say, luxurious.

 Luxury Is Fluid And In The Eyes of the Beholder

 

While early researchers appeared to be focused on motivations like status, exclusivity, and self-expression, more recent researchers have suggested that the perception and meaning of luxury are far more complex than this. Infering luxury, much like love and attraction, is in the eyes of the beholder. In the same way, we fall in love for many reasons; we consider something luxurious for multiple reasons, too. Quite often, one person’s assessment being different to another’s. Notwithstanding, like love, some change their feelings along the way! Therefore, rather than being easy to define, it is a complex, multi-faceted concept. Wided Batat (2023), in his paper The Pursuit of Luxury or Luxuries? A Framework of the Past, Present, and Future of Luxury Research, wrote:

“an evolving and multidimensional construct. It encompasses several meanings that individuals assign to it according to the norms and codes of their consumption cultures. These meanings evolve over time, influenced by social and individual changes. Luxury is also closely tied to the culture and practices of the group in which it emerges, shapes, and develops.“

This evolving, multiple influences and social changes, where meaning moves over time, has resonance with my own lived experiences. For example, Tag Heuer (Tag) and Omega in my twenties felt highly desirable and luxurious watches, aspirational when I didn’t have one. Contrast this to today, nearly thirty years later. Having owned two Tags and many friends and peers owning one or more, these two brands, as lovely as their watches are, now feel more mainstream, normalised, rather than luxurious. Subsequently, brands such as Patek Phillippe and Vacheron Constantin have taken their place in my perception of a highly desirable, genuinely luxurious watch. But this is just my context, my perception. And while I might get excited by artisan-crafted luxury Swiss watches, it is probably less so for a younger audience that is more comfortable and familiar with a technically and socially connected world. In their case, while I might not consider any Apple or Garmin watch luxurious, some younger and/or sporting individuals will probably disagree, particularly regarding a top-of-the-range Apple Ultra 2 or Garmin’s Fenix 8.

Luxury Develops A More Prominent Social Conscious

 

As Batat alludes, not only is the meaning of luxury multi-faceted, it is also fluid, with the definition of luxury today constantly moving and influenced by social choices and changes in our interconnected world.  This can be illustrated in the prominent role of sustainability and ethical considerations in many luxury brands, including our own (e.g. environmental policy). This aligns with Kapferer and Bastien (2012), who suggest that luxury offerings must adapt to changing consumer values, with modern consumers seeking brands that demonstrate social responsibility and exclusivity. Take Bentley as an example; whereas a V12  (gas-guzzling) engine might have been the epitome of luxury 25 years ago, today, it is not, and Bentley is consequently committed to being carbon neutral and only producing more environmentally friendly hybrids and electric vehicles by 2030.

Summary – And the Luxury Relationship With Ski Holidays

 

In conclusion, luxury can be understood from multiple dimensions and perspectives. No one owns this word or its interpretation. On one hand, luxury is often associated with opulence and exclusivity. For example, a luxury ski holiday may include staying in top resorts with gourmet dining, private ski instructors, and access to world-class slopes. This perspective emphasises high-end experiences, premium service, and the prestige of elite skiing destinations. Conversely, luxury can also be defined more holistically, encompassing personalized experiences, connection to nature, and overall well-being. A luxury ski holiday may not solely hinge on high costs or lavish accommodations but instead focus on the quality of the experience, such as enjoying breathtaking views, engaging in mindful skiing, and fostering meaningful connections with friends or family.

 

With evolving consumer values highlighting sustainability and ethical considerations, luxury is increasingly linked to responsible tourism practices. In our sector, ski holidays that prioritize eco-friendly accommodations or promote the local culture can also be considered luxurious in a modern context. All in all, luxury is far more than just motivating people based on exclusivity, status, and self-esteem, as early theorists suggested. Today’s definition of luxury is fluid and multifaceted, blending traditional notions of craftsmanship, style, exclusivity, and opulence with contemporary values of experience, sustainability, and personal fulfilment. This inclusive understanding allows for broader interpretations, appealing to diverse consumer preferences in the luxury ski holiday sector and all other luxury markets.

This article was written by Mark Leyshon, MCIPS, MSc in People and Organisational Development.

Bibliography:

  1. Batat, W. (2023). The pursuit of luxury or luxuries? A framework of the past, present, and future of luxury research. Consumption Markets & Culture, 26(2), 103–116. https://doi.org/10.1080/10253866.2023.2185233
  2. Eastman, J. K., Goldsmith, R. E., & Flynn, L. R. (1999). Status Consumption in Consumer Behavior: Scale Development and Validation. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, 7(3), 41–52. https://doi.org/10.1080/10696679.1999.11501839
  3. Kapferer, J.-N., & Bastien, V. (2009, January). The Luxury Strategy: Break the Rules of Marketing to Build Luxury Brands. ResearchGate. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/281251957_The_Luxury_Strategy_Break_the_Rules_of_Marketing_to_Build_Luxury_Brands
  4. Pine, J., & Gilmore, J. H. (2013). The Experience economy: past, Present and Future. ResearchGate. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/260917972_The_experience_economy_past_present_and_future
  5. Veblen, T. (1899). The Theory of the Leisure Class. Economica, 13, 95. https://doi.org/10.2307/2548014

;