Luxury Is Fluid And In The Eyes of the Beholder
While early researchers appeared to be focused on motivations like status, exclusivity, and self-expression, more recent researchers have suggested that the perception and meaning of luxury are far more complex than this. Infering luxury, much like love and attraction, is in the eyes of the beholder. In the same way, we fall in love for many reasons; we consider something luxurious for multiple reasons, too. Quite often, one person’s assessment being different to another’s. Notwithstanding, like love, some change their feelings along the way! Therefore, rather than being easy to define, it is a complex, multi-faceted concept. Wided Batat (2023), in his paper The Pursuit of Luxury or Luxuries? A Framework of the Past, Present, and Future of Luxury Research, wrote:
“an evolving and multidimensional construct. It encompasses several meanings that individuals assign to it according to the norms and codes of their consumption cultures. These meanings evolve over time, influenced by social and individual changes. Luxury is also closely tied to the culture and practices of the group in which it emerges, shapes, and develops.“
This evolving, multiple influences and social changes, where meaning moves over time, has resonance with my own lived experiences. For example, Tag Heuer (Tag) and Omega in my twenties felt highly desirable and luxurious watches, aspirational when I didn’t have one. Contrast this to today, nearly thirty years later. Having owned two Tags and many friends and peers owning one or more, these two brands, as lovely as their watches are, now feel more mainstream, normalised, rather than luxurious. Subsequently, brands such as Patek Phillippe and Vacheron Constantin have taken their place in my perception of a highly desirable, genuinely luxurious watch. But this is just my context, my perception. And while I might get excited by artisan-crafted luxury Swiss watches, it is probably less so for a younger audience that is more comfortable and familiar with a technically and socially connected world. In their case, while I might not consider any Apple or Garmin watch luxurious, some younger and/or sporting individuals will probably disagree, particularly regarding a top-of-the-range Apple Ultra 2 or Garmin’s Fenix 8.